Friday, October 23, 2009

My Diaper Report

I have many Mommy friends right now and I am very thankful for the knowledge and experience they provide! (You know who you are girls… Thank You!!!) Currently, a little less than half of my Mommy friends use (or want to start using) cloth diapers. So I decided to do a detailed report diaper report. It’s more for me to get my thoughts together, but I hope to also use it to explain to all why we are deciding to use cloth diapers.

Cloth What?

Now, let me tell you… the world of cloth diapers is way complicated… at first… it gets easier, I promise. There are several different styles (or methods) and brands and different ways to folds and snaps and Velcro and even a bungee/snappy thing? It is very interesting and overwhelming at the same time. The only real way to decide is to talk to moms who are doing or have done cloth diapers before and hear their thoughts on things. I feel much better about it and even excited about trying them, but to explain it to you let me show you some pictures…

Pre-folds with covers: the traditional rectangular piece of fabric that you fold around your baby can secure with a snappi (used to use safety pin). The cover is to protect the clothing from getting wet… it’s made out of a non permeable material and does not have to be wash with every use (usually washed every 2-3 changes). Video1. Video2. Video3.

Pocket Diapers: designed just like a disposable diaper and just as easy to put on. The pocket allows you to put extra liners in and allows for less diaper changes. They are more expensive, require a wash after every use and take longer to dry. We hope to receive them as gifts, but may purchase a few for the convenience on trips and with baby sitters. Also… bumgenius (also runs cottonbabies.com) gives diaper grants to missionaries so we really want to purchase this brand whenever possible. Video1. Video2.

All-in-ones: This eliminates the stuffing part of the pocket diapers, you could still put an additional liner in at night but it would be similar to the pre-fold method. I have heard that they take a very long time to dry and that they tend to wear out sooner. Video.

One-sized: very similar to the all-in-ones, except snaps allow you to adjust the size (first link is for a pocket-one-sized diaper). Video.

And the list carries on as far as options go. For the diaper with a cover system, you can have… pre-folds, fitted liners, flat liners, or contour liners with fleece covers, wool covers or synthetic covers. Sorry I didn’t research them all. I more interested in what I have seen work with my friends.

We decided to go with… pre-folds and covers during the day and pocket diapers for the evening, sitters or trips with some disposables when necessary. Pre-folds are the easiest to clean and pocket diapers not only allow for double liners at night time but they also make cloth diapers easy for guest who want to help out with the baby. Our friends that use pre-folds don’t bother with snappies because the cover holds the diaper in place. I like the idea of one-sized diapers but Steven feels they may be too bulky and he is right!

Pros and Cons

Disposable Diapers
Pros
-convenient & easy
-no extra laundry
-everyone knows how to use them
Cons
-will permanently take up space in a landfill
-have to buy them continuously
-may take longer to potty train (disposables are designed to keep babies dry and as a result they don’t know when they are wet)
-some studies say babies have more diaper rash with disposable.

Cloth Diapers
Pros
-they don’t produce waste to fill landfills
-more economical
-less chemicals on baby’s precious bottom
-may be easier to potty train (babies know that they are wet)
-reusable with each child (in fact the more kids you have the more money you save)
-cloth diapers have come a long way… with the new advances they are almost as easy as disposable!

Cons
-have to clean with every use
-increased laundry
-may leak
-can’t use them with diaper rash ointment (ointment can reduce absorbency because it is designed to repel water.)
-need special soap to wash them (some detergents cause a waxy build up and can reduce absorbency)
-not as easy to travel with (you have take your dirty diapers with you)

My Thoughts

I hate the idea of contributing to our growing landfill problem!!! However, like my husband I have a passion for saving money… so I don’t mind a little extra work to help reduce the waste I put into the landfill. We already compost and recycle… I fell like this is the next responsible step when it comes to good stewardship with our planet.

I am also very excited about the potty training thing.

I’m not too worried about the cleaning and extra washing concerns… if I start with the first baby they day we bring him/her home then I won’t notice the disposable vs. cloth diaper difference. Besides, it turns out we already use the “correct” detergent! Some recommend soaps are Dreft, Ivory, All Free Clear, and Charlie’s Soap.

About diaper rash… it happens… and we can run and purchase a small pack of disposables... we may them for nursery visits at church anyway.

You may wonder about the extra water used. Well, we believe that water is a more renewable reasource than landfills. God designed our water to be re-cycled... evaporation, rain, etc...

Being responsible with God's creation (earth) and saving money are our reasons for using cloth diapers.

Cost Breakdown

Here is my break down on cost.

Average Changes per day
(this is what I calculated by. It may be off by a bit, but I wanted to just picked some numbers, based off of online research, so that I could compare cost)
0-3m.................................... 12 times a day
3-8m.................................... 8 times a day
8-15m................................. 6 times a day

(((most cost were based off of what Steven and I register for at Amazon and Target)))



4 comments:

  1. You are my nerd hero for actually doing the math on the diaper comparison! My numbers are even better because of the freeness of my cloth diapers. Don't forget to ask around to see if anyone is giving theirs away!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks! We hope to recieve many diapers as gifts or give-a-ways.... I just wanted to see what the numbers punched out as... and also explain to the family what a cloth diaper looks like today. Anyway... I was AMAZED to see that it was 60% cheaper to use cloth diapers... my initial guess was that it was going to be around 10% cheaper.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I just found a hybrid diaper, reusable cover, flushable liner. Or, you can compost the liner: www.gdiapers.com. They are also sold at Cloud9Baby.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Maybe I'll do a follow up post on the hybrids. I love their covers! Especially the little pink one with ruffles!

    speaking of cloud9baby... We need to take a trip with MacKenzie... she was wondering where it was.

    ReplyDelete